◂ Griffey Card Prices — interactive guideCharts90sWax

The 10 Most Expensive 1991 Ken Griffey Jr. Cards

· 4 min read · real eBay sold prices

1991 Topps Operation Desert Shield #790 Ken Griffey Jr. in PSA 9 slab
Topps · Desert Shield #790

Last week was 1990. This week it's 1991, and the top of this list is a different animal: three of the top three are Topps variations most collectors never saw in a pack. Here are the ten most expensive 1991 Griffey sales I track, ranked by price. All real eBay sales.

10. 1991 Fleer #450 "Bat Around .300" — PSA 10

$137.50 on eBay auction (Oct 7)

The yellow set. There are two versions of the back: the error that says "Bat Around .300" and the corrected "Bat .300," and PSA now labels them separately. The error is the scarcer one — just 89 PSA 10s. Great photo of Griffey on the front, which is more than you can say for most of 1991 Fleer.

9. 1991 Donruss MVP #392 — PSA 10

$162.50 on eBay auction (Oct 13)

The MVP subset card. PSA 10 population: 222. Nothing fancy, it's just a clean 10 of a card everyone had, and those keep inching up — it sold for $175 in November.

8. 1991 Score Dream Team #892 — PSA 10

$192 best offer (Oct 14)

The black-and-white Dream Team insert from Score packs — one of the most recognizable Griffey cards of the era. PSA 10 population is 939, so it's not scarce, but it's iconic. (Softened to $135 a few weeks later, so $192 looks like the top for now.)

7. 1991 Score All-Star #396 — PSA 10

$222.50 on eBay auction (Oct 13)

The illustrated big-head All-Star card. PSA 10 population: 539. This one kept going after the video — it sold for $266 on November 6.

6. 1991 O-Pee-Chee Premier #56 — PSA 10

$230 best offer (Aug 4)

The Canadian premium set, and this copy is centered perfectly. Pop report: 686 graded, 280 PSA 9s, 79 PSA 10s. That's a tough ratio for a card that still sells for under $300 — one to watch.

5. 1991 Ultra Gold #4 — PSA 10

$282 on eBay auction (Sep 19)

I own a few of these and they are very hard to gem. The backs are routinely off-center and the corners don't stay clean. A sharp PSA 10 like this one is the exception, and the price shows it.

4. 1991 Studio #112 — PSA 10

$380 best offer (Sep 23)

The first Studio set, with the portrait photography that made it famous. PSA 10 population: 174. I'll be honest — in the listing photo it almost looks like one corner has lifted. Could be the picture. I'd want to see this one in hand.

3. 1991 Topps Desert Shield All-Star #392 — PSA 9

$1,475 on eBay auction, 43 bids (Oct 11)

The All-Star card with the Desert Shield logo in the top right. These were shipped to troops in the Gulf, and they're tough — and increasingly faked. Look closely at the logo, and under a black light the real ones fluoresce at the corners of the back. A PSA 9 at $1,475 on 43 bids tells you how much demand there is for the real thing.

2. 1991 Topps Tiffany #790 — PSA 10

$1,655 on eBay auction, 41 bids (Oct 11)

The glossy factory-set version of the base card. PSA 10 population 102 out of 516 graded. This copy looks straight out of the pack, with a recent cert number — maybe a hair heavy left-to-right, but a beautiful card. Forty-one bids.

1. 1991 Topps Desert Shield #790 — PSA 9

$2,551 on eBay auction, 30 bids (Sep 13)

The base card with the Desert Shield stamp. Pop report: 200 PSA 9s, 28 PSA 10s. I don't have a recent PSA 10 sale to compare against, and I'm sure it would be a big number. Sharp corners on the back of this one, and 30 bidders agreed. This is the most expensive 1991 Griffey, and it isn't close.

What this list says about 1991

Seven of the ten sold for under $400. The other three are all 1991 Topps variations — Desert Shield All-Star #392 ($1,475), Tiffany #790 ($1,655) and Desert Shield #790 ($2,551) — and nothing else on the list is within $1,000 of them. For scale, the regular 1991 Topps #790 in a PSA 10 last sold for $201. Same photo, same design: the Tiffany gloss is worth about 8 times that, and the Desert Shield stamp about 12 times, in a lower grade. If you're going through 1991 Topps, check the front for the Desert Shield logo and the back for the glossy finish before you assume it's a common.

← All articles

Browse the guide
Prices updated November 18, 2026 from real eBay sold listings · Not affiliated with PSA, eBay, or Topps · Built for collectors, by a collector
A 90sWax site · griffeycardprices.com · Site Map · YouTube · Instagram